Boise Junior College v. Mattefs Construction

From wikilawschool.org. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
Boise Junior College v. Mattefs Construction
Court Idaho Supreme Court
Citation 450 P.2d 604
Date decided February 7, 1969

Facts

Mattefs Construction Company ("Mattefs") submitted a bid of $141,048 to Boise Junior College District ("Boise") for a Boise construction project.

However, in calculating its bid, Mattefs had mitakenly omitted the cost of glass & windows. The lowest bid Mattefs had received from its glass & windows sub-contractors was $19,741.


The bids were opened on October 5th 1965.

Procedural History

Boise entered into a construction contract with the next-highest bid & simultaneously sued Mattefs on the bid bond with Matteffs over the $7,000 bid difference.

The trial court ruled that Mattes was entitled to rescission because it has under-estimated its bid by accident. Boise lost.

Issues

Is a bidder who makes a clerical error in preparing a bid entitled to the equitable remedy of rescission?

Holding

Yes. A bidder who makes an innocent error in preparing a bid may be entitled to rescission.

Resources